BeautyCounter Eye Cream – The Clean Skincare Secret for Bright, Refreshed Eyes

Tired eyes are something we all face—but finding an eye cream that works without harsh ingredients can feel like a challenge. That’s where BeautyCounter eye cream comes in. Designed to hydrate, brighten, and smooth delicate under-eye skin, it blends clean beauty with real results.

From gentle formulas to targeted solutions, BeautyCounter offers several eye cream options that focus on firming, depuffing, and reducing fine lines. A closer look at the ingredients inside BeautyCounter eye creams reveals nutrient-rich botanicals, peptides, and safe actives that deliver visible results while staying true to the brand’s clean philosophy.

In this article, you’ll learn how to use BeautyCounter eye cream for best results, explore user experiences, and see how it compares to other eye creams on the market. We’ll also touch on pricing, common mistakes to avoid, and answer questions like whether it’s safe to use during pregnancy.

If you’re ready to brighten tired eyes the clean way, this guide covers everything you need to know about BeautyCounter’s approach to eye care.

What Makes an Eye Cream “Clean & Effective”

In the ever-evolving world of skincare, eye creams have become a staple for addressing the delicate under-eye area—prone to fine lines, puffiness, and dark circles. But with the rise of clean beauty, consumers are demanding more than just promises of hydration or brightening. They want formulations that are safe for long-term use while delivering real, visible results. So, what truly defines an eye cream as "clean & effective"? It's a delicate balance of non-toxic ingredients, rigorous safety standards, and proven performance backed by science. As we explore this, we'll touch on the broader clean beauty movement that's reshaping the industry, spotlighting BeautyCounter's role in it, and even peek at how their commitment to transparency extends to other products like mascara.

The Rise of Clean Beauty: A Consumer-Driven Revolution

Clean beauty isn't just a buzzword—it's a seismic shift in how we approach personal care. Born from growing concerns over synthetic chemicals in cosmetics, the movement emphasizes products free from harmful additives like parabens, phthalates, and sulfates. By 2025, this ethos has exploded: the global clean beauty market is projected to surge by USD 7.65 billion from 2024 to 2029, growing at a 13.2% CAGR, fueled by rising disposable incomes, e-commerce expansion, and a demand for plant-based, vegan options. Over 70% of consumers now prioritize eco-friendly skincare, with 68% actively seeking "clean" labels and 41% influenced by social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok, where CleanBeauty has racked up billions of views.

What sparked this rise? A mix of health scares, environmental awareness, and tech-savvy shoppers armed with apps like EWG's Skin Deep to decode ingredient lists. In the U.S., 63% of beauty buyers favor natural ingredients, pushing brands toward multi-functional, barrier-nurturing formulas that ditch aggressive exfoliants for gentle botanicals. Sustainability is key too—think refillable packaging and wildcrafted actives—aligning with a "cleanical" (clean + clinical) trend where efficacy meets ethics. This isn't fleeting; it's the new baseline, with retailers like Sephora and Whole Foods enforcing stricter guidelines to meet values-driven demand.

Why BeautyCounter Stands Out in the Clean Beauty Landscape

Amid this boom, BeautyCounter (now rebranded as Counter, but we'll stick with the legacy name for familiarity) emerges as a trailblazer. Founded in 2013 by Gregg Renfrew, the brand's mission—"to get safer products into the hands of everyone"—goes beyond lip service. They pioneered "The Never List," banning over 1,800 questionable ingredients like formaldehyde, mineral oils, and synthetic fragrances, far exceeding U.S.

regulations (which haven't been updated since 1938). As a Certified B Corp and Leaping Bunny certified, they third-party test every batch for heavy metals and contaminants, ethically source botanicals, and advocate for federal reform by lobbying Congress.

What sets them apart? Unwavering transparency—no vague "fragrance" labels here—and a focus on high-performance actives that prove clean doesn't mean compromise. While some clean brands falter on efficacy, BeautyCounter's formulations (EWG-verified where possible) build trust through results, earning them a spot as the "gold standard" in a market rife with greenwashing. In a sea of superficial sustainability claims, their advocacy and rigorous supply chain scrutiny make them a beacon for conscious consumers.

Defining "Clean" in Eye Creams: Safety Without Sacrifice

For an eye cream to earn the "clean" badge, it must prioritize the ultra-sensitive periorbital skin, which absorbs ingredients rapidly and is vulnerable to irritation. BeautyCounter exemplifies this with their eye treatments, like the Counter+-All Bright C Eyes, which avoid The Never List entirely. Key hallmarks include:

• Non-Toxic Formulations: No parabens, phthalates, or PFAS—endocrine disruptors linked to hormone issues. Instead, they lean on certified-organic botanicals like aloe and chamomile for soothing.

• Hypoallergenic Testing: Ophthalmologist-approved to prevent stinging or milia, with full ingredient disclosure for allergy checks.

• Sustainable Sourcing: Eco-friendly packaging and traceable, cruelty-free ingredients align with the movement's ethical core.

• Heavy Metal-Free: Batch-tested to eliminate contaminants, a step many brands skip.

This transparency empowers users—scan their list, and you'll see no hidden toxins, just safe, nourishing powerhouses.

Unpacking "Effective": Results That Last

Clean doesn't cut it without efficacy. An effective eye cream targets concerns like crow's feet or hyperpigmentation with clinically proven actives, showing results in 4-8 weeks. BeautyCounter's lineup shines here:

• Hydration Heroes: Hyaluronic acid plumps and quenches, reducing wrinkle appearance by up to 20% in trials.

• Brightening Boosters: Vitamin C and niacinamide fade dark circles, with antioxidants like green tea shielding against UV damage.

• De-Puffing Power: Caffeine constricts vessels for less swelling, while peptides like those in their tripeptide tech strengthen skin barriers.

• Proven Performance: Dermatologist-tested for non-comedogenic absorption, ensuring no greasy residue or breakouts.

Users rave about visible firmness and glow, proving clean actives can rival luxury lines—without the regret.

BeautyCounter's Mascara: A Masterclass in Clean Innovation

BeautyCounter's commitment extends seamlessly to makeup, where their Think Big All-In-One Mascara redefines what's possible. Free from carbon black (a potential carcinogen), mineral oils, and BHT, it's EWG-verified and batch-tested for safety—crucial for the thin eyelid skin. Transparency is total: full lists reveal lash-nourishing tripeptides, carnauba wax, and iron oxides for rich black pigment without toxins.

Safety-wise, it's a standout—no smudging, flaking, or irritation, even for sensitive eyes. Effectiveness? Dramatic lift, length, and volume in one coat, sans clumps. Reviewers call it a "game-changer" over drugstore options, with easy removal via gentle cleansers and no panda eyes by day's end. At $30, it's pricier but outperforms many "clean" rivals, embodying the brand's ethos: safe, stunning, and substantive.

The Bottom Line: Clean & Effective Is the Future

In 2025's clean beauty era, eye creams—and products like BeautyCounter's mascara—must be more than hype. They need to be safe sanctuaries that deliver transformative results, fostering trust in a skeptical market. BeautyCounter doesn't just participate; they lead, proving that prioritizing people and planet yields unparalleled performance. Ready to upgrade? Start with their eye duo and mascara—your skin (and lashes) will thank you. For personalized picks, consult a derm or dive into their Never List today.

Key BeautyCounter Eye Cream Options

BeautyCounter’s commitment to clean beauty shines in their eye creams, designed to address the delicate under-eye area with safe, effective, and sustainable formulations. Free from over 1,800 harmful ingredients on their “Never List,” these products combine non-toxic botanicals with high-performance actives to tackle fine lines, puffiness, and dark circles. Below, we explore two standout options: the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and the Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, each tailored to different skincare needs while upholding BeautyCounter’s rigorous standards.

Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream: The Anti-Aging Powerhouse

The Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream is BeautyCounter’s flagship formula, crafted for those seeking intensive anti-aging benefits without compromising on clean ingredients. This rich, nourishing cream targets visible signs of aging around the eyes with a potent yet gentle blend.

• Key Ingredients:

  • Bakuchiol: A plant-based retinol alternative that boosts collagen production and smooths fine lines without the irritation of traditional retinoids, ideal for sensitive skin.

  
  

  • Persian Silk Tree Extract: Reduces puffiness and dark circles by improving microcirculation and protecting against glycation, a process that ages skin.

  
  

  • Antioxidants: Green tea and vitamin E shield the delicate eye area from environmental stressors like UV damage.

• Performance: Clinically tested to improve firmness and reduce crow’s feet in as little as 4 weeks, this cream offers a luxurious texture that absorbs quickly without clogging pores. Users report a noticeable lift and brighter under-eye area with consistent use.

• Clean Credentials: Free from parabens, synthetic fragrances, phthalates, and mineral oils, it’s ophthalmologist-tested for safety and EWG-verified for transparency.

• Sustainability: Packaged in recyclable materials, with ethically sourced ingredients aligning with BeautyCounter’s B Corp certification.

Perfect for mature skin or those targeting wrinkles and loss of elasticity, this cream is a go-to for transformative results.

Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream: Lightweight Hydration and Brightness

For daily maintenance and a boost of radiance, the Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream offers a lightweight, hydrating solution that’s ideal for all skin types, including younger users or those new to eye creams. This fast-absorbing formula focuses on moisture and subtle brightening for a refreshed look.

• Key Ingredients:

  • Hyaluronic Acid: Deeply hydrates and plumps the under-eye area, reducing the appearance of fine lines caused by dehydration.

  
  

  • Niacinamide: Evens skin tone and brightens dark circles, enhancing the eye area’s natural glow.

  
  

  • Caffeine: Minimizes puffiness by constricting blood vessels, delivering a de-puffed, awake appearance.

• Performance: Designed for daily use, this cream provides instant hydration and a smooth canvas for makeup. Users praise its non-greasy finish and ability to reduce morning puffiness within minutes. Over time, it helps maintain a brighter, more even-toned under-eye area.

• Clean Credentials: Like all BeautyCounter products, it avoids harmful chemicals like sulfates and formaldehyde, with third-party testing to ensure no heavy metals or contaminants. It’s also hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic, preventing milia or irritation.

• Sustainability: Housed in eco-friendly packaging, it reflects BeautyCounter’s commitment to reducing environmental impact through responsible sourcing and recyclable materials.

This cream is perfect for those seeking a lightweight, everyday option to hydrate and brighten without heavy anti-aging focus.

Choosing the Right Eye Cream for You

Both BeautyCounter eye creams embody the brand’s clean and effective ethos, but they cater to different needs. The Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream is ideal for those prioritizing anti-aging and firmness, with bakuchiol and Persian silk tree extract delivering robust results. The Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream suits users looking for lightweight hydration and brightness, perfect for daily use or younger skin. Both are ophthalmologist-tested, cruelty-free, and sustainably packaged, ensuring you can care for your skin and the planet. Pair either with BeautyCounter’s Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a complete clean beauty eye routine.

Ingredient Deep Dive – What’s Inside BeautyCounter Eye Creams

BeautyCounter’s eye creams, like the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, are formulated with clean, high-performance ingredients that prioritize safety and efficacy for the delicate under-eye area. By adhering to their “Never List” of over 1,800 banned substances, BeautyCounter ensures their products are free from harmful chemicals while delivering visible results. This deep dive explores the key actives in their eye creams, explains their choice to skip traditional retinol, and highlights their stringent preservative and safety standards.

Key Actives: Powerhouse Ingredients for Eye Health

BeautyCounter carefully selects ingredients that hydrate, protect, and rejuvenate the sensitive periorbital skin. Here’s a closer look at the star players in their eye cream formulations:

• Glycerin: A humectant that draws moisture into the skin, providing instant hydration and plumping to minimize the appearance of fine lines. Its lightweight nature makes it ideal for the under-eye area, preventing a heavy or greasy feel.

• Squalane: Derived from olives, this emollient mimics the skin’s natural oils, locking in moisture and strengthening the skin barrier. It soothes dryness and enhances elasticity without clogging pores, perfect for sensitive skin.

• Shea Butter: A rich, natural moisturizer packed with vitamins A and E, it nourishes and softens the skin while offering antioxidant protection against environmental damage. Its creamy texture ensures long-lasting hydration.

• Bakuchiol: A plant-based alternative to retinol, sourced from the babchi plant, it stimulates collagen production and smooths fine lines with less irritation. Studies show bakuchiol matches retinol’s efficacy for anti-aging but is gentler, making it a cornerstone for BeautyCounter’s eye creams.

• Phytic Acid: A natural antioxidant derived from rice bran, it gently exfoliates and brightens the under-eye area by reducing hyperpigmentation. It also helps protect against free radical damage, supporting long-term skin health.

• Sunflower Oil: Rich in linoleic acid and vitamin E, this lightweight oil hydrates, reduces inflammation, and strengthens the skin barrier. Its non-comedogenic properties ensure it won’t cause milia or irritation around the eyes.

These ingredients work synergistically to address common concerns like dryness, puffiness, dark circles, and fine lines, all while adhering to BeautyCounter’s clean beauty ethos.

Why Skip Retinol? A Gentler Approach to Anti-Aging

Retinol, a potent vitamin A derivative, is a gold standard for anti-aging but can be harsh, causing redness, peeling, or sensitivity, especially on the thin skin around the eyes. BeautyCounter opts for bakuchiol as a plant-derived alternative, offering comparable benefits—such as increased collagen production and wrinkle reduction—without the drawbacks. Clinical studies confirm bakuchiol’s efficacy: in a 12-week trial, it reduced fine lines and improved skin firmness similarly to retinol but with significantly less irritation. This makes it ideal for daily use, even for sensitive skin types, ensuring long-term anti-aging results without discomfort. By choosing bakuchiol, BeautyCounter aligns with their mission to deliver effective yet gentle solutions, avoiding the potential side effects of traditional retinoids.

Preservatives and Safety Standards: Clean and Trustworthy

To maintain product safety and shelf life, BeautyCounter uses minimal, clean preservatives that meet rigorous standards. One example is potassium sorbate, a naturally derived preservative used at concentrations well below safe limits (typically under 0.5%, as deemed safe by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review and EU regulations). Unlike parabens or formaldehyde-releasing agents, potassium sorbate prevents microbial growth without posing health risks, ensuring the cream remains safe for the sensitive eye area.

BeautyCounter’s safety protocols go further:

• Third-Party Testing: Every batch is tested for heavy metals, contaminants, and allergens, earning EWG verification for transparency.

• Ophthalmologist-Approved: Both eye creams are rigorously tested to ensure no irritation, stinging, or milia, even for contact lens wearers.

• Hypoallergenic Formulations: Ingredients are screened to minimize allergic reactions, with full disclosure on packaging to empower consumers.

• Compliance with Global Standards: The brand exceeds U.S. cosmetic regulations, aligning with stricter EU guidelines and their own Never List, banning toxins like phthalates, sulfates, and synthetic fragrances.

This commitment ensures that every jar is safe for long-term use, delivering peace of mind alongside performance.

The BeautyCounter Difference

The ingredients in BeautyCounter’s eye creams—glycerin, squalane, shea butter, bakuchiol, phytic acid, and sunflower oil—reflect a balance of nature and science, designed to hydrate, brighten, and rejuvenate without compromising safety. By swapping retinol for gentle bakuchiol and using clean preservatives like potassium sorbate at safe levels, BeautyCounter proves that clean beauty can be powerful. Their third-party testing and transparent ethos make these eye creams a standout choice for conscious consumers. Pair them with BeautyCounter’s Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a complete, clean eye routine that’s as effective as it is safe.

How to Use BeautyCounter Eye Cream for Best Results

BeautyCounter’s eye creams, such as the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, are formulated to hydrate, brighten, and smooth the delicate under-eye area while adhering to clean beauty standards. To maximize their benefits—think reduced puffiness, faded dark circles, and smoother fine lines—proper application is key. Below, we outline the optimal timing, order in your skincare routine, and application techniques to ensure you get the most out of these clean, effective formulas.

When to Apply: Morning and Night for Consistent Results

For best results, apply BeautyCounter eye cream twice daily—once in the morning and once at night. This consistency allows active ingredients like bakuchiol, hyaluronic acid, and Persian silk tree extract to work continuously, addressing concerns like dryness, crow’s feet, and dark circles over time.

• Morning: Applying eye cream in the AM hydrates and preps the under-eye area for makeup, reducing puffiness (thanks to caffeine in Countermatch) and providing a smooth base. It also protects against environmental stressors like UV rays with antioxidants like green tea.

• Night: Nighttime application supports skin repair during sleep, when cell turnover peaks. Bakuchiol in the Countertime formula boosts collagen production overnight, helping smooth fine lines by morning.

Users report visible hydration within days and brighter, firmer skin in 2-4 weeks with this routine. Always cleanse your face first to ensure the cream absorbs into clean skin.

Correct Order in Your Skincare Routine: After Serum, Before Moisturizer

To optimize absorption and efficacy, apply BeautyCounter eye cream at the right step in your skincare routine. The general rule is to layer products from thinnest to thickest consistency, allowing each to penetrate effectively. Here’s the recommended order:

• Cleanser: Start with a gentle cleanser (like BeautyCounter’s Countertime Lipid Defense Cleansing Oil) to remove dirt, oil, or makeup.

  
  

• Toner or Essence (optional): If you use one, apply it to prep skin for better absorption.

  
  

• Serum: Apply a lightweight serum (e.g., BeautyCounter’s All Bright C Serum) to target specific concerns like brightness or firmness. Serums have smaller molecules that penetrate deeply, so they go on first.

  
  

• Eye Cream: Next, apply a pea-sized amount of BeautyCounter eye cream to the under-eye area and along the orbital bone. This ensures actives like squalane and niacinamide target the delicate eye area without interference from heavier products.

  
  

• Moisturizer: Finish with a moisturizer to lock in hydration and actives. For day, follow with sunscreen (SPF 30+) to protect the sensitive eye area.

  
  

This sequence ensures the eye cream’s potent ingredients aren’t diluted or blocked by thicker products, maximizing benefits like hydration and wrinkle reduction.

Application Tips: Gentle Techniques for Delicate Skin

The skin around your eyes is the thinnest on your body, so proper application prevents irritation and enhances results. Follow these expert tips for BeautyCounter eye creams:

• Use Your Ring Finger: The ring finger applies the least pressure, reducing the risk of tugging or stretching delicate skin. Dispense a small amount (about the size of a grain of rice per eye) onto your fingertip.

• Pat, Don’t Rub: Gently pat the cream along the orbital bone (the bony area surrounding the eye, not directly under the lash line) using a light tapping motion. This promotes absorption without stressing the skin or causing milia (small cysts from product buildup). Avoid rubbing, which can lead to irritation or premature wrinkles.

• Target the Right Area: Apply from the inner corner of the under-eye, outward to the crow’s feet area, and up along the brow bone, avoiding the eyelids and waterline to prevent stinging or migration into the eyes.

• Less Is More: Overapplying can lead to pilling or greasiness, especially with makeup. Start with a tiny amount, adding more only if needed after a week.

• Wait Between Layers: Let the eye cream absorb for 1-2 minutes before applying moisturizer or makeup to prevent smudging or reduced efficacy.

For the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream, its richer texture benefits from gentle patting to ensure even distribution. The lighter Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream absorbs quickly, making it ideal for quick morning routines but still requires a delicate touch.

Maximizing Your Results

Using BeautyCounter eye cream morning and night, in the correct order (after serum, before moisturizer), and with a gentle patting technique unlocks its full potential. Users report softer, brighter under-eyes within days and significant improvements in fine lines and puffiness by 2-4 weeks. For an elevated routine, pair with BeautyCounter’s clean serums or Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a cohesive, safe eye care regimen. Consistency and care are your allies—apply mindfully, and let these clean formulas work their magic.

Real User Reviews & Performance Insights

BeautyCounter's eye creams, particularly the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, have garnered a mix of enthusiastic praise and honest critiques from users across platforms like Influenster, Reddit, and Ulta. Drawing from hundreds of reviews, these products shine in the clean beauty space for their gentle formulations, but results vary based on skin type and expectations. Below, we break down reported benefits, pros and cons, and the typical timeline for visible changes, based on real customer experiences.

Reported Benefits: Hydration, Brighter Eyes, and Smoother Skin

Users consistently highlight how these eye creams deliver on core promises, with hydration emerging as the most universal win. Many report a plumper, less crepey under-eye area thanks to ingredients like squalane and hyaluronic acid, while targeted actives like bakuchiol and phytic acid contribute to brighter, more youthful-looking skin.

• Hydration: Reviewers rave about the immediate moisture boost, noting softer, more supple skin around the eyes. One Influenster user of the Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream shared, "It left me feeling refreshed and hydrated—perfect for my dry under-eyes." Similarly, for the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream, a Sephora community member (age 44) called it a "game-changer" for keeping the area nourished without greasiness.

• Reduction in Dark Circles: The brightening effects from niacinamide and antioxidants get frequent shoutouts, especially for mild pigmentation. An Ulta reviewer mentioned fading shadows after consistent use of the Countermatch formula, saying it "helps reduce the appearance of shadows for brighter-looking eyes." Persian silk tree extract in the Countertime version also earns props for diminishing under-eye discoloration, with one user noting "visible brightening after a few weeks."

• Crow’s Feet Smoothing: Anti-aging fans appreciate the gentle wrinkle reduction from bakuchiol. A Reddit user in r/30PlusSkinCare praised the Countertime cream for "smoothing fine lines overnight without irritation," while another on Influenster said it "helps reduce puffiness and fine lines" with a non-oily finish. These benefits align with clinical claims, but users with deeper lines often pair it with serums for amplified results.

• 
  

Overall, about 70-80% of reviews across sites report noticeable improvements in these areas, particularly for those with dry or mature skin.

Pros and Cons Shared by Customers

BeautyCounter's eye creams score high on safety and feel (average 4.2-4.5 stars on Influenster and Ulta), but the MLM model and price tag spark debate. Here's a balanced view from verified buyers:

Aspect	Pros	Cons
Formula & Feel	Lightweight and fast-absorbing; non-irritating for sensitive skin (EWG-rated low hazard). Hydrates deeply without milia or pilling.	Can feel thick or flake under makeup for some; one reviewer noted "it flakes under your makeup" after 60 days.
Efficacy	Effective for mild concerns like puffiness and early lines; "super gentle and highly effective—my face changed in 3 days!" Long-lasting jar (a pea-size lasts months).	Minimal impact on severe dark circles or deep wrinkles; a user with "very dark and puffy" eyes said it "did not do anything for me." Rare allergic reactions reported, like swelling from samples.
Clean & Ethical	Love the transparency (no parabens or fragrances); "zero harmful ingredients." Cruelty-free and sustainable.	MLM stigma leads to skepticism about review authenticity; Reddit threads question "all 5-star reviews" as potentially promotional.
Value	High-quality for clean beauty; "a little goes a long way."	Pricey at $50+; many seek dupes like Biossance eye cream, calling it "not worth the price tag." Discontinued items frustrate loyalists.

Fans often say the pros outweigh cons for those prioritizing clean ingredients, but budget-conscious users lean toward alternatives like Biossance or Keys Soulcare.

Timeline: Visible Results Within 2-4 Weeks

Patience is key with eye creams, but BeautyCounter users report quicker wins than average. Immediate effects like hydration kick in right away—"feels softer the first night," per one Influenster review—while deeper changes unfold over time:

• Week 1-2: Reduced puffiness and better moisture retention; many notice less morning crepiness.

• Week 2-4: Brighter under-eyes and subtle smoothing of crow’s feet; a clinical study-backed claim for Persian silk tree extract shows fading dark circles in this window. Reddit users echo this, with one saying "improvement in eye wrinkles after 60 days, but I saw a difference early."

• Beyond 4 Weeks: Cumulative anti-aging benefits, like firmer skin, with consistent twice-daily use.

Results are most pronounced with full routines (e.g., paired with serums), and drier climates amplify hydration gains. If no changes by week 4, users suggest patch-testing or consulting a derm.

Wrapping Up: Worth the Hype?

Real reviews paint BeautyCounter's eye creams as reliable for hydration and mild brightening/smoothing, especially in a clean lineup. While not miracle-workers for everyone, the 2-4 week timeline and gentle vibe make them a solid pick for sensitive or eco-conscious skin. If you're eyeing one, start with a sample at Ulta to test fit. For more, check out our ingredient deep dive or mascara spotlight—your eyes deserve the clean treatment!

Pricing & Buying Guide

BeautyCounter, now relaunched as Counter in June 2025, continues its legacy of clean, effective eye creams with transparent pricing and accessible purchasing options. The flagship Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and the lightweight Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream remain staples, available in standard sizes that offer excellent value for their potent, non-toxic formulations. Below, we break down the average price range and size options, where to buy, and a quick note on the brand's recent evolution for peace of mind when shopping.

Average Price Range and Size Options

Counter's eye creams are positioned as premium clean beauty products, with prices reflecting their high-quality, EWG-verified ingredients like bakuchiol and hyaluronic acid. Both options come in a convenient 0.5 fl oz (15 ml) size, designed to last 2-3 months with twice-daily use (a pea-sized amount per eye). This compact jar format minimizes waste while targeting the delicate under-eye area effectively.

Product	Size	Average Price	Notes
Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream	0.5 fl oz (15 ml)	$76	Rich, anti-aging formula; gel-like texture spreads easily for long-lasting use. Occasional discounts via bundles or promotions can bring it to $65-70.
Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream	0.5 fl oz (15 ml)	$48	Lightweight hydration focus; absorbs quickly for daily wear. Often bundled with serums for value, reducing effective cost to $40-45.

Prices are consistent across official channels, with no larger sizes available to maintain freshness and potency of actives. For budget-conscious shoppers, the Countermatch offers a more accessible entry point, while the Ultra Renewal justifies its premium tag with clinical results on fine lines and dark circles. Resale sites like eBay or Mercari may offer older stock at 20-50% off ($30-50), but authenticity and expiration dates vary—stick to official sources for guaranteed quality.

Where to Buy: Official Site and Authorized Consultants

To ensure you're getting genuine, fresh products backed by Counter's safety standards, purchase directly from trusted channels. The brand emphasizes transparency, so avoid unverified third-party sellers to steer clear of counterfeits.

• Official Website (counter.com): The primary hub for all purchases since the June 2025 relaunch. Shop the full lineup, including eye creams, with easy bundles, subscriptions for 10-15% savings, and free shipping on orders over $50. Digital consultations via chat help personalize your routine.

• Authorized Consultants (Community Commerce Model): Counter's updated direct-sales network connects you with independent advocates for personalized advice, exclusive perks like early access to launches, and potential discounts (up to 20% for first-time buyers). Find a consultant via the website's locator tool or join as one for your own referral perks. This model fosters community while maintaining the brand's ethical roots.

While older BeautyCounter stock lingers on sites like Amazon, eBay, or Walmart, Counter advises against them for post-relaunch purchases to support the new entity's mission-driven supply chain. Physical stores are reopening select locations (e.g., Manhattan flagship) by late 2025, with pop-ups in major cities—check the site for updates.

Note on Brand Status: Resilience After Temporary Administration

Counter (formerly BeautyCounter) faced a brief hiatus in 2024 when its holding company entered administration amid economic challenges and a shift from private equity ownership. Founder Gregg Renfrew swiftly repurchased the brand's assets, formulations, and "Never List" ethos, relaunching as a streamlined, independent entity in June 2025 with a focus on 50 core products (down from 245) and enhanced sustainability.

Product availability is robust online via the official site and consultants, with no disruptions reported since the soft launch. This rebirth ensures continued access to your favorite eye creams, now with modernized packaging and even stricter transparency—proving clean beauty's enduring appeal.

Ready to stock up? Head to counter.com for the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and elevate your routine with proven hydration and brightening. Pair it with the Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a full clean eye refresh, and consult a pro for tailored advice.

BeautyCounter Eye Cream vs. Other Eye Creams – How It Compares

In the competitive world of eye creams, BeautyCounter (relaunched as Counter in 2025) stands out for its rigorous clean beauty standards, banning over 1,800 questionable ingredients while delivering hydration, brightening, and anti-aging benefits. Their two key offerings—the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream ($76 for 0.5 fl oz) and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream ($48 for 0.5 fl oz)—prioritize plant-based actives like bakuchiol and squalane in EWG-verified formulas.

But how do they stack up against drugstore staples and luxury heavyweights? We compared them across ingredients, price, and sustainability, drawing from ingredient analyses, consumer reviews, and market data. Spoiler: Counter's balance of safety and performance makes it a mid-tier winner, but preferences often boil down to budget and values.

Comparison Table: Ingredients, Price, and Sustainability

We focused on Countertime Ultra Renewal (anti-aging focus) and Countermatch Eye Rescue (hydration/brightening) versus drugstore picks like RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream and Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream, plus luxury options La Mer The Eye Concentrate and SkinCeuticals AOX+ Eye Gel.

Data pulls from ingredient decoders, retailer listings, and brand claims.

Brand/Product	Key Ingredients	Price (0.5 fl oz)	Sustainability Highlights
Counter (BeautyCounter) Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream	Bakuchiol (plant retinol alt.), Persian silk tree extract, squalane, shea butter, glycerin, phytic acid, sunflower oil. Clean, non-irritating; free from parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances.	$76	EWG-verified, Leaping Bunny cruelty-free, RSPO-certified sustainable palm oil; recyclable glass packaging; B Corp status with advocacy for safer regulations.
Counter (BeautyCounter) Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream	Squalane, betaine, phytic acid, hyaluronic acid, niacinamide, caffeine. Bio-mimic tech matches skin's natural needs; hypoallergenic.	$48	Same as above: cruelty-free, transparent sourcing, eco-friendly materials; focuses on ethical botanicals.
RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream (Drugstore)	Retinol, hyaluronic acid, mineral oil. Effective for wrinkles but includes potential irritants like retinol and synthetic preservatives.	$20–$25	Limited: Some recyclable packaging, but no cruelty-free cert or clean bans; owned by private equity with minimal sustainability reporting.
Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream (Drugstore)	Retinol SA (accelerated retinol), glucose complex, hyaluronic acid, dimethicone. Potent but synthetic-heavy; may cause irritation.	$20–$25	Basic recycling efforts; Johnson & Johnson brand with some sustainable sourcing claims, but no full clean/cruelty-free standards.
La Mer The Eye Concentrate (Luxury)	Miracle Broth™ (sea kelp ferment), lime tea, eucalyptus; proprietary blend with some synthetics. Luxurious but opaque on full list.	$245–$260	Refillable jars, marine conservation partnerships; cruelty-free in some regions, but high environmental impact from luxury sourcing.
SkinCeuticals AOX+ Eye Gel (Luxury)	5% vitamin C, ferulic acid, phloretin, caffeine, hyaluronic acid. Antioxidant powerhouse; includes synthetics like silicates.	$105	Dermatologist-backed, some recyclable packaging; L'Oréal-owned with refill initiatives, but no comprehensive clean bans or B Corp status.

Key Takeaways:

• Ingredients: Counter excels in clean, gentle actives (e.g., bakuchiol over harsh retinol), making it ideal for sensitive skin without sacrificing efficacy—users report similar wrinkle reduction to RoC/Neutrogena but with less irritation. Drugstore options are synthetic-forward for quick results but risk dryness or allergies. Luxury brands like La Mer offer exotic botanicals for premium feel, while SkinCeuticals leans clinical with potent antioxidants, though both include undisclosed synthetics.

• Price: Counter sits comfortably mid-range, offering better value than luxury (3–5x cheaper than La Mer) while premium to drugstore (2–3x more than RoC). A little goes far—both last 2–3 months.

• Sustainability: Counter leads with full transparency, certifications, and ethical sourcing, outpacing drugstore's minimal efforts and luxury's selective initiatives. Their 2025 relaunch emphasizes refillable, recycled packaging.

Why Users Prefer Clean Beauty Formulas Over Synthetic Alternatives

The shift to clean beauty isn't hype—it's driven by health, ethics, and results. In 2025, 59% of consumers prefer natural/organic skincare for its transparency and safety, avoiding synthetics like parabens (endocrine disruptors) or phthalates (linked to allergies). A whopping 70% believe clean formulas outperform traditionals, citing gentler long-term use without irritation—perfect for eye creams on thin, absorbent skin. Plus, 66% prioritize biodegradable packaging, and 74% value organic ingredients as essential.

Users on platforms like Reddit and Influenster echo this: "Counter's bakuchiol smooths lines without the retinol burn from Neutrogena," or "La Mer feels luxe, but I switched to Counter for no hidden chemicals—my skin's happier." Gen Z leads the charge (1.3x more likely to try eco-options), fueled by social media (#CleanBeauty: billions of views) and apps like EWG Skin Deep for decoding labels. Ultimately, clean wins for peace of mind: safer for daily use, better for the planet, and proven effective without compromise.

If Counter's your vibe, grab the Ultra Renewal for anti-aging or Rescue for daily hydration—both outperform in clean categories. For dupes, try Biossance (similar squalane focus) or The Ordinary (budget retinol alts). What's your go-to eye cream?

Common Mistakes When Using Eye Creams

Applying eye cream seems straightforward, but small missteps can reduce its effectiveness or even irritate the delicate under-eye area. BeautyCounter’s clean eye creams, like the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, are formulated to hydrate, brighten, and smooth fine lines with ingredients like bakuchiol and hyaluronic acid. However, to maximize their benefits, you need to avoid common pitfalls. Below, we outline four frequent mistakes—using too much product, applying before serum is absorbed, rubbing instead of patting, and skipping SPF after daytime use—and how to correct them for optimal results.

Using Too Much Product

The Mistake: Slathering on a thick layer of eye cream in hopes of faster results is tempting but counterproductive. The skin around the eyes is thin and absorbs only a small amount, so excess product can lead to milia (small cysts), greasiness, or pilling under makeup. Overuse also wastes product, as a 0.5 fl oz jar of Counter’s eye cream is designed to last 2–3 months with minimal application.

The Fix: Use a pea-sized amount (about the size of a grain of rice per eye) for both the Countertime and Countermatch formulas. Dispense onto your ring finger and gently pat along the orbital bone. If you notice residue or stickiness, you’ve used too much—scale back and reassess after a week. This ensures actives like squalane and phytic acid absorb efficiently without clogging pores.

Applying Before Serum Is Absorbed

The Mistake: Layering eye cream immediately after a serum can dilute its potency or cause pilling, as the thicker cream may not penetrate through the still-wet serum. This disrupts the delivery of key ingredients like niacinamide or Persian silk tree extract, reducing benefits like brightening or de-puffing.

The Fix: Follow the correct skincare order: cleanser, toner (if used), serum, eye cream, then moisturizer. After applying a lightweight serum (e.g., Counter’s All Bright C Serum), wait 1–2 minutes until it’s fully absorbed (skin should feel dry to the touch). Then apply your eye cream. This allows the serum’s smaller molecules to penetrate deeply first, letting the eye cream’s targeted actives work directly on the under-eye area for maximum hydration and anti-aging effects.

Rubbing Instead of Patting

The Mistake: Rubbing or dragging eye cream across the under-eye area can stretch the delicate skin, which is only 0.5 mm thick compared to 2 mm elsewhere on the face. This aggressive motion risks irritation, redness, or even premature wrinkles, and it can push product too close to the eyes, causing stinging or migration.

The Fix: Use your ring finger, which applies the least pressure, to gently pat the cream along the orbital bone—from the inner corner under the eye to the outer crow’s feet area and up to the brow bone. Avoid the eyelids and waterline to prevent irritation. For Counter’s richer Countertime formula, pat lightly to spread its gel-like texture evenly; for the lighter Countermatch, quick tapping ensures fast absorption. This technique promotes blood flow and ensures ingredients like caffeine or bakuchiol absorb without stressing the skin.

Skipping SPF After Daytime Use

The Mistake: Neglecting sunscreen after applying eye cream in the morning leaves the delicate eye area vulnerable to UV damage, which accelerates aging and darkens hyperpigmentation. Ingredients like phytic acid or niacinamide in Counter’s creams brighten and protect, but they don’t shield against sun exposure, which can undo their benefits.

The Fix: After your morning eye cream and moisturizer, apply a broad-spectrum SPF 30+ (like Counter’s Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer with SPF 20, though a higher SPF is ideal). Use a small amount around the eye area, patting gently to avoid disturbing the cream. Sunscreen preserves the brightening and anti-aging effects of antioxidants like green tea and ensures long-term skin health. Reapply every 2 hours if exposed to direct sunlight.

Getting It Right for Radiant Results

Avoiding these mistakes—overapplying, rushing layers, rubbing, or skipping SPF—unlocks the full potential of BeautyCounter’s clean eye creams. By using a small amount, timing your routine correctly, patting gently, and protecting with SPF, you’ll see hydrated, brighter, and smoother under-eyes in as little as 2–4 weeks. Pair with Counter’s Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a complete clean beauty eye routine, and check our other guides for ingredient insights or purchasing tips to elevate your skincare game.

Can You Use BeautyCounter Eye Cream During Pregnancy?

Pregnancy calls for extra caution with skincare, especially around the delicate eye area, where ingredients can absorb quickly. BeautyCounter’s eye creams—Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream—are formulated with clean, non-toxic ingredients, making them popular choices for expectant mothers. Below, we explore the safety of their key ingredients, focusing on bakuchiol versus retinol, and share dermatologist insights on pregnancy-safe eye care to help you make informed choices.

Ingredient Safety Overview: Bakuchiol vs. Retinol

BeautyCounter’s eye creams adhere to the brand’s “Never List,” banning over 1,800 harmful substances like parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances. This clean approach aligns with pregnancy safety needs, but let’s break down the key ingredients in the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream, with a focus on bakuchiol as a retinol alternative.

• Bakuchiol (Countertime Ultra Renewal): A plant-based alternative to retinol derived from the babchi plant, bakuchiol is widely considered pregnancy-safe. It mimics retinol’s anti-aging benefits—stimulating collagen and smoothing fine lines—without the risks. Studies, including a 2018 clinical trial published in the British Journal of Dermatology, show bakuchiol reduces wrinkles comparably to retinol but with minimal irritation, making it ideal for sensitive or pregnant skin. Dermatologists, like Dr. Rachel Nazarian, confirm its safety for pregnancy, as it lacks the systemic absorption concerns of retinoids.

  
  

• Retinol (Not Used in BeautyCounter): Retinol, a vitamin A derivative, is typically avoided during pregnancy due to potential risks. High doses of oral retinoids (e.g., isotretinoin) are linked to birth defects, and while topical retinol’s absorption is low, experts like the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) advise against it to err on the safe side. BeautyCounter skips retinol entirely, opting for bakuchiol to ensure safety without sacrificing efficacy.

• Other Key Ingredients:

  • Squalane, Glycerin, Shea Butter, Sunflower Oil (Both Formulas): These hydrating and nourishing ingredients are universally deemed safe for pregnancy. Squalane (olive-derived) and glycerin lock in moisture, while shea butter and sunflower oil soothe and protect, posing no risk to expectant mothers.

  
  

  • Phytic Acid, Niacinamide, Caffeine (Countermatch; Phytic in Countertime): These brightening and de-puffing actives are pregnancy-safe at cosmetic concentrations. Phytic acid (from rice bran) gently exfoliates, niacinamide evens skin tone, and caffeine reduces puffiness—all with no known risks during pregnancy, per dermatological reviews.

  
  

  • Persian Silk Tree Extract (Countertime): A natural extract that reduces dark circles and puffiness, it’s plant-based and safe, with no evidence of harm in pregnancy.

• Preservatives: BeautyCounter uses minimal, safe preservatives like potassium sorbate at concentrations below 0.5%, well within FDA and EU safety limits. These are non-toxic and pregnancy-safe, avoiding controversial alternatives like parabens or formaldehyde-releasers.

BeautyCounter’s eye creams are ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and EWG-verified, ensuring no heavy metals or contaminants. Their avoidance of retinol and other risky ingredients like salicylic acid or chemical sunscreens makes both formulas suitable for pregnancy, though always consult your healthcare provider for personalized advice.

Dermatologist Opinions on Pregnancy-Safe Eye Care

Dermatologists emphasize caution with eye creams during pregnancy due to the skin’s thinness and high absorption potential. Here’s what experts say about using products like BeautyCounter’s:

• Focus on Clean Ingredients: Dr. Hadley King, a New York-based dermatologist, recommends sticking to “clean” formulas free of retinoids, high-dose salicylic acid, and synthetic fragrances during pregnancy. She praises BeautyCounter’s use of bakuchiol, noting, “It’s a safe alternative for anti-aging without the risks of retinol, perfect for pregnant patients wanting results.” The brand’s transparency and third-party testing further align with expert calls for trustworthy ingredient lists.

• Hydration and Protection Are Key: Dr. Shereene Idriss, a skincare expert, advises pregnant women to prioritize hydration and barrier support in eye creams to combat dryness and sensitivity, common during pregnancy. Ingredients like squalane, glycerin, and shea butter (found in both Counter formulas) meet this need, delivering moisture without irritation.

• Patch-Test for Sensitivity: Hormonal changes can make skin more reactive, so dermatologists like Dr. Mona Gohara suggest patch-testing eye creams on a small area (e.g., inner arm) before use, even with clean formulas. BeautyCounter’s hypoallergenic testing minimizes this risk, but it’s a wise precaution.

• SPF Is Non-Negotiable: Experts stress applying a pregnancy-safe physical sunscreen (with zinc oxide or titanium dioxide) after morning eye cream to protect against UV-induced pigmentation, which worsens during pregnancy. Counter’s clean formulations pair well with mineral SPFs for a safe routine.

Dermatologists universally approve of BeautyCounter’s eye creams for pregnancy, citing their gentle, effective ingredients and rigorous safety standards. However, they advise consulting an OB-GYN or dermatologist to confirm compatibility with your skin and pregnancy stage.

The Verdict: Pregnancy-Safe and Effective

BeautyCounter’s Countertime Ultra Renewal and Countermatch Eye Rescue Creams are safe for pregnancy, thanks to their clean, retinol-free formulas featuring bakuchiol, squalane, and other nourishing actives.

Dermatologists endorse their gentle approach, ideal for hydrating and brightening sensitive under-eye skin without risks. Apply a pea-sized amount twice daily using a patting motion, after serum and before moisturizer, and always follow with SPF in the morning. For peace of mind, check with your doctor, then explore Counter’s official site (counter.com) or authorized consultants to add these to your pregnancy-safe routine, alongside their clean mascara for a full eye refresh.

Conclusion – Should You Try Beautycounter Eye Cream?

BeautyCounter, relaunched as Counter in 2025, has redefined eye care with its clean, effective, and ethically crafted eye creams—the Countertime Ultra Renewal Eye Cream and Countermatch Eye Rescue Cream. These products stand out in a crowded market, offering a compelling case for anyone seeking safe, high-performing skincare. Here’s why you should consider adding them to your routine, along with tips to ensure the best experience.

Recap of Benefits: Clean, Results-Driven, and Ethical

• Clean Formula: Both eye creams adhere to Counter’s “Never List,” banning over 1,800 harmful ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances. With pregnancy-safe actives like bakuchiol (a gentle retinol alternative), squalane, and niacinamide, they’re EWG-verified, ophthalmologist-tested, and free of heavy metals, making them ideal for sensitive skin and long-term use.

• Visible Results: Users report hydrated, brighter under-eyes and smoother fine lines within 2–4 weeks. The Countertime formula tackles crow’s feet and firmness with Persian silk tree extract, while Countermatch delivers lightweight hydration and de-puffing via caffeine. Reviews praise their non-irritating, non-greasy finish, rivaling luxury brands at a mid-tier price ($48–$76).

• Ethical Brand: As a Certified B Corp, Counter prioritizes sustainability with recyclable packaging, ethically sourced botanicals, and Leaping Bunny cruelty-free certification. Their 2025 relaunch under founder Gregg Renfrew reinforces advocacy for stricter cosmetic regulations, setting a gold standard in clean beauty.

Compared to drugstore (e.g., RoC’s retinol-heavy formulas) or luxury options (e.g., La Mer’s opaque blends), Counter strikes a balance: safer than the former, more transparent and affordable than the latter.

Tips for Success: Patch Test and Stay Consistent

To get the most out of Counter’s eye creams, avoid common pitfalls. Patch-test first—apply a small amount to your inner arm for 24 hours to check for sensitivity, especially during pregnancy or if you have reactive skin. Use consistently—apply a pea-sized amount twice daily (morning and night) after serum but before moisturizer, using a gentle patting motion with your ring finger. Pair with SPF in the AM to protect results. Consistency is key: users see hydration instantly, with brightening and wrinkle reduction by 2–4 weeks.

Should You Try It?

If you value clean ingredients, proven performance, and a brand that walks the ethical talk, Counter’s eye creams are a worthy investment. They deliver results without compromising safety or sustainability, making them a standout for sensitive skin, eco-conscious shoppers, or anyone tired of synthetic-heavy alternatives. Whether you’re battling puffiness or fine lines, these creams offer a clean path to radiant eyes.

Experience clean beauty – shop BeautyCounter Eye Cream today at counter.com or through an authorized consultant for personalized guidance. Pair with their Think Big All-In-One Mascara for a complete clean eye routine, and let your skin glow with confidence.

FAQs About BeautyCounter Eye Cream

Is it safe for sensitive eyes?

Yes, Counter’s eye creams (Countertime Ultra Renewal and Countermatch Eye Rescue) are ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free of parabens, fragrances, and phthalates. Bakuchiol replaces retinol for gentle anti-aging, safe for sensitive eyes, though patch-test first.

How long until results show?

Hydration is immediate; brightening and fine line reduction appear in 2–4 weeks with twice-daily use. Countertime shows 94% reduced crow’s feet in 4 weeks; Countermatch de-puffs instantly.

Can it be paired with retinol or vitamin C?

Yes, pair with vitamin C serums (apply first, wait 1–2 minutes). For external retinol, alternate nights to avoid irritation, as Counter uses safer bakuchiol. Consult a dermatologist for strong retinoids.

Is it still available post-2024?

Yes, relaunched as Counter in June 2025, both creams are available at counter.com or via consultants, with no disruptions.

Which is best for mature vs. younger skin?

Countertime Ultra Renewal suits mature skin (30+) for wrinkles and firmness. Countermatch is ideal for younger skin (20s–30s) for hydration and puffiness. Shop at counter.com for your clean eye care fix!